Recap, I Thought We Were *SUPPOSED* To Sing

Posted on July 31st, 2008 in Church Life, Faith, Worship Leadership by Fred

Hey Everybody!
(special thanks to Steve Lowe for the image idea!)

So I never thought this week’s blog material would turn into a series. But did it ever. The response from you all has been incredible, and obviously - I’ve touched on something that we’re eager to discuss.

It all started with a recap of my experience this past Sunday morning as a “worshiper” in the congregation, as opposed to the Worship Leader, or someone running sound, producing, etc.

I followed up with a recap and incredible perspective from a former college professor, Dr. Michael Braz. He had some thoughts that really made us think.

As promised, I’m coming back today to close it up. I’d hoped to get this thing out first thing this morning; however I had lots of last-minute things to complete for SSCC before leaving town … that’s right … leaving town - we (the family) are headed up to Gainesville for some family time on Lake Lanier. We’re turning the McKinnon Manor here on St. Simons Island into a party home for house-sitting pals, Jay and Brooke.

In summary, I think there are tons of reasons that people aren’t singing in our churches.

  • maybe the music isn’t loud enough, and their self conscious about their voice
  • maybe the songs are too contemporary, too new, or in a key they aren’t comfortable with
  • maybe they’ve been “trained” by our entertainment culture to watch instead of participate
  • maybe they are engaged in worship, but they are overwhelmed by God’s Presence and can’t sing
  • maybe they just don’t care … they aren’t being drawn in
  • maybe they haven’t been taught enough
  • maybe they’ve been “taught wrong”

and on, and on, and on.

I believe all of these could have some huge impacts on our corporate participation (or lack thereof).

However, as I prayed about this a while back, I felt like the Holy Spirit gave me this thought. It’s simple, yet profound:

“Without revelation, there won’t be much participation”.

Did you get that?

You see, when we get a revelation of God … how awesome He is, how huge He is, how loving He is, how compassionate He is, and all the amazing things that He has selflessly done FOR US … we can’t help but respond and participate.

So, if that’s the case - how do we see our people get a better revelation of “God”. Pray, certainly. Teach, absolutely.

I’ll be doing my best to publish tomorrow’s “FreePlay Friday” by morning … in the meantime, closing thoughts?

Fred

Pt 2, Corporate Singing (with words from Dr. Michael Braz)

Posted on July 29th, 2008 in Church Life, Faith, General, Worship Leadership by Fred

Hello Everyone,

For those who missed it, I published what I thought could be a risky blog nearly 24 hours ago. “I Thought We Were *SUPPOSED* to Sing” was perhaps one of the most ignited, passionate, engaging posts that I’ve had with the “comments” here in a long time. It was AWESOME seeing so many of you come out of “hiding” to leave your responses.

One such response came to me “off-blog” … via private email. It came from someone I respect and trust deeply. Someone who I had the privilege of studying under for four wonderful years at Georgia Southern University in Statesboro, GA. His name is Dr. Michael Braz.

Dr. Braz is an amazing and talented individual. I wanted to post some of his thoughts because they were quite stirring. Dr. Braz defines his religious views on his Facebook profile as “Reform Judaism with Buddhist sympathies”. So these thoughts don’t necessarily come from a “Protestant/Christian” point of view, but from a spiritual, professional, and musical point of view.

He was gracious enough to give me permission to publish this. I will come back and offer my thoughts with Part 3 on Thursday, and we’ll all come together for some fun on FreePlay Friday.

It’s an easy read, I’ve highlighted and inserted a few thoughts for emphasis … here we go:

Hi, Fred–

… It may surprise you to find that I keep up with your
writing/performing/opinionating, etc. (as I also do with Russ Hutto and
other GSU music alumni). The reality of our working in two quite different
worlds in no way dampens my fascination with the way you are growing in your
chosen vocation.

One of these days–I don’t know when, but I hope it’s soon–we’ll sit down
for a meal and tackle some of the common annoyances of the world. One
example might be how we condition people to be audiences, rather than
participants. Another might be how we intimidate people away from using
their singing voices (children are especially adept at teasing their
parents–especially their fathers–who try singing in church).
[Fred says, "sign me up for this class and let's broadcast it on Mogulus]

Again, keep in mind that I am a very happy and willing stranger to the
terrain of praise bands, competing blogs (and breaches of blog etiquette),
intramural church politics, etc. On the other hand, I have just spent 9
months overseas supplementing my appreciation of spiritual traditions in a
variety of settings, especially Hindu and Buddhist. It’s somewhat ironic,
when you consider that my fascination towards comparative religions began as
a 16-year-old high school senior in Miami, stepping in at the last minute
for a pianist at a week of Baptist revivals, and that I served St. Matthew’s
Catholic Church (Statesboro) for 2 years as its first paid music director.

What I think I’m trying to say here–with limited success–is this: people
are willing to be entertained, especially by those they perceive as doing
something better than them (music, sports, acting). At the same time, they
are a result of their conditioning, which serves as a sort of straitjacket
limiting their modes of expression.

At any rate, there is much to talk about, should you ever find your way up
here. You might even bring a digital recorder–I have been known to take
requests. [note to self, Fred ... this is an open invitation to get what could be the only live recording of one of the most amazing Gershwin "I've Got Rhythm" piano solos ever known.  I want it.]

All the best,

Michael Braz

Now there’s some words to chew on, my friends.

Comments? I’ll be back with mine on Thursday. Stay tuned.

I Thought We Were *SUPPOSED* To Sing?

Posted on July 28th, 2008 in Church Life, Music, Worship Leadership by Fred

Todd Fields, Jekyll Island Fun in the Son, Photo By Chris Moncus Photography, ChrisMoncus.Com
(photo courtesy of Chris Moncus)

Hey Everyone,

First of all, a huge “thanks” to all the worship leaders and churchgoers who participated in the first “Sunday Setlists” theme over the last 24 hours. We had 13+ (and growing) people check in and post their setlists on their blogs, linking back and forth. We’ll start doing that weekly, so be watching every Sunday/Monday morning.

Since I was gone all last week, I wasn’t scheduled to lead worship this Sunday - I just observed and worshiped from the congregation.

I think every Worship Leader should schedule themselves “off the stage” now and then - gain some perspective of what it looks and feels like “in the room”.

I floated around the back part of the auditorium. I love my church, but what I witnessed grieved me deeply. The overall majority of people weren’t engaged at all. They weren’t singing. I looked around in amazement … trying not to pass judgment … but in my heart, I was grieved. Why do so many people come to church and stand there, stoic, with no desire to engage in singing and celebration? Granted, I’d just returned from an incredible week of 2,000+ people who loved to worship through music and song.

In the 11:00 service I joined my wife and sister-in-law for the service. I had an aisle seat, a few rows from the back. As soon as the band begin to play and Shannon began to lead, I did what comes naturally. I began to sing. What happened next surprised me even more. As soon as I started to sing, I had heads turning back for up to three rows in front of me … turning around as to say “who is that, what are you doing”?.

Is the “back of the church” is where you go if you don’t want to engage? Maybe the fact that we’re pressured to run our sound at lower-than-optimum levels makes one feel they can’t raise their voice from fear of being too loud. (How do you win? If you sing, you’re louder than the room, if you turn the music up, more people sing, and more people complain!?)

Don’t get me wrong - we have an amazing church, with a diverse background … which is part of what makes it so amazing. But as the person whose calling and ministry it is to LEAD this congregation into “worship in spirit and truth” … I have to express this experience and ponder these thoughts.

As for me, I sang … yet, I was the one who seemed to be distracting people.

… I just wanted to shrug my shoulders and say “Oh, I’m sorry … I thought we were *SUPPOSED* to sing.

Sunday Setlists #1 - Join the Carnival

Posted on July 27th, 2008 in Church Life, Sunday Setlists by Fred

Sunday Setlists, #1 (a new Blog Carnival)

(yes, this is the Sunday Surprise, so join in!)

Introduction:
Recently, I’ve been introduced to a few sites using a technique called the “Blog Carnival” to build community on their blogs. The “blog carnival” helps the blogger (with incoming links) and the participants (with outgoing links and exposure) as a result of participating. Some of the blog carnivals I’ve participated in include the “Watercooler Wednesday” with Randy Elrod and “Creative Chaos” with RagamuffinSoul.com.

After making lots of new friends, bloggers, twitters, and bringing quite a few new subscribers on board, I thought it would be fun to pull everyone together weekly for a blog carnival called “Sunday Setlists”.

Choosing a topic such as “setlists” greatly reduces the number of people who can participate in the carnival … I realize that, but I’ve chosen this topic because it’s of genuine interest to me. I really enjoy seeing what other people are singing in their churches, and I think most of you enjoy it as well. By having everyone link on “Mr. Linky” it will be easy to visit other’s blogs and see their “Sunday Setlists”.

The Rules:

Each Sunday, I’ll post a recap of our Sunday Setlist. It may be a Worship Confessional video or a “textfessional” (a written setlist). You are encouraged to do the same thing. As a matter of fact, if your worship pastor doesn’t blog, feel free to post a recap for your church .. you don’t have to be the leader!

1. Post your blog entry with your Sunday Setlist recap.
2. In your blog, you should link back to this post (the most current Sunday Setlist) and indicate that you are posting your setlist as part of the “Sunday Setlists” theme. Feel free to copy and paste this description:
“This week’s recap of songs is posted in collaboration with other worship leaders on the “Sunday Setlists” blog carnival at www.fredmckinnon.com”.
3. After posting your blog, fill out the “Mr. Linky” form below, with your name, and the URL to your “Sunday Setlist” blog entry. (please don’t just link to your blog’s homepage, or the link will be deleted - the idea is that we can all easily click over and see your setlist).
4. Leave a comment below letting us know you’re participating.

I think this will be a lot of fun … so many of us are already posting our weekly setlists, and this is a way to allow everyone else to see each other’s setlist posts easily. Got questions? Just leave a comment below.

Sunday Setlist for Sunday, July 27
St. Simons Community Church
Worship Leader: Shannon Lewis

Songs:
“All I Have”, Charlie Hines (iTunes link)
“No Other Name”, by Todd Fields (iTunes link)
“Jesus Paid It All” (Kristian Stanfill Arr.) (iTunes link)
“How Deep the Father’s Love For Us”, by Stuart Townend (iTunes link)
“Mighty To Save” by Hillsongs Australia (iTunes link)

Ok, so post your setlist, link back to this post as part of the “Sunday Setlists” group, and then include your name and link back to your Sunday Setlists post in the Mister Linky below.

Then, come back and see everyone’s setlists as it grows.
Fred

This “Sunday Setlists” is now closed - below are the links to other worshiper leader’s and church attender’s Worship Confessionals, Textfessionals, and recaps:

1. Billy Chia
2. Fred McKinnon (Mister Linky Test)
3. Jamie Burnside
4. Rick Scheibner
5. Steve Lowe
6. Jim Drake (Worship Post-Fessional)
7. Bobby Gilles
8. Ryan Egan
9. HL McConnell
10. Mandy (GCC rocked it)
11. Paul Joseph
12. Gary Durbin
13. Russ Hutto
14. Klampert (CECWorship)
15. Ben Abu Saada
16. Wayne Thomas
17. Matt Stevens
18. Jon Morris
19. mandythompson
20. Grupo de Alabanza - ICCM
21. JonWesley Barnhill

Powered by… Mister Linky’s Magical Widgets.

Sunday … Surprise

Posted on July 26th, 2008 in General by Fred

Good evening everyone,

Many of you won’t see this until the surprise is “no more”.  It’s 10:45 PM EST on Saturday evening … and tomorrow morning, most likely before noon … I’ll have a Sunday Surprise.  It’s going to be fun, it’s going to build community, networking, and should bring some excitement around here.

On Sunday?  What, the SLOWEST DAY of the week for blogworld?

Yep - and you’ll see why.

Check back often tomorrow … ’cause the “early bird gets the worm”.

See you tomorrow.  Are you ready?

Fred