Age-Focused and Preference-Driven

Posted on March 31st, 2010 in Church Life, Faith by Fred McKinnon

It’s Spring Break here in Glynn County to I’ve taken a few days off of work so we can be together as a family.  We were hanging out on the beach yesterday and I read a great article from LeadershipJournal.Net called “The X Factor“.

“Most of the highly celebrated, experimental worship services launched in the 90′s to reach ‘Gen-X’ are now gone.  What have we learned from the rise, decline, and renewal of next generation ministries?” … that’s the headline.  It was a great read.

I suppose reading this article and Skye Jethani’s “The Divine Commodity” at the same time is creating a firebox where the slightest spark can ignite the inferno inside of me, that, for a bunch of reasons, sometimes thinks we’re “doing church” all wrong these days.

I’m constantly living in this tension … how to be relevant and attractive to those who need (and yes, even to those who have) Jesus Christ … and how to live the life that Jesus has for us, with authenticity and holiness.   How to take relate to this culture without being tainted by it’s filthy influence.

One quote in this article really pulled a verbal “Amen” from me … right out loud, there on the pool deck.

I feel that if we can see church as the people, and not just define church by the worship gathering, a lot would be solved in bridging generations,” Kimball said. “We could focus more on the older mentoring the younger, the older opening their homes and being sages and guides to the younger. Instead we focus so much on getting the twenty-somethings into the main worship gathering. But just sitting in a room for an hour and half looking at the backs of everyone’s heads does not make something intergenerational.

Wow.  You see, I have this desire that we all come together.  There is a time and place for “age-focused and preference-driven” gatherings, but I don’t think they should become the all-in-all for people.  Seems like God has something for us all to learn from one another.  But we don’t really accomplish that through our Sunday morning gatherings in most churches.  Like the quote above says, we come and look at the back of people’s heads and go home.

This needs to change.  How do we go beyond the corporate worship and lecture and become family?

1.  I feel that entertainment-driven corporate gatherings are creating weak Christians who constantly focus on what is “in it” for them.
2.  I feel that by constantly appealing to “preference” we feed the self-fulfillment monster and isolate those who don’t share the same preference.
3.  I think that we miss the building of true community when our church activities revolve around the big events where someone on stage performs for us.

Ouch.  There.  I said it.

Let the debate begin.


  • merry

    No debate from me! I agree completely.

    I am so tired of hearing about “us v. them” and “what I like”. It’s not about any of us as individuals at all. It’s about Jesus and the church as a whole.

    There is so much that is lost when so many aspects of life are age-segregated. Older people have so many things they can teach younger people. And younger people have so much enthusiasm to share with older people.

    • http://www.fredmckinnon.com Fred McKinnon

      Merry,
      I agree .. but even if we can get them together, does the typical format of our gatherings really lend itself to this type of upward/downward mentoring and serving?

      • merry

        I don’t think so.

        When my husband was a youth minister, we had our teens do service projects for some older people a couple times a year (raking leaves, cleaning gutters, etc.) We also planned, cooked, and served a dinner for the senior saints group at church. The seniors often returned the kindness with extra money for activities on mission trips, cards of encouragement, and other things like that. Those are things that all took place outside of our Sunday morning gatherings but greatly contributed to the health of our congregation.

        My 11 y.o. son is actually spending the day with a 70 y.o. man today who has taken an interest in mentoring him. They are doing a community service project for Boy Scouts together. I am very grateful for this man’s heart as he is actively involved in our local Scout troop and has become an extra grandparent for many of these boys.

        I have no idea how to incorporate any of that into our gatherings, but I do know that continually feeding the “what I want” or “us v them” mentality is definitely not helping.

        • http://www.fredmckinnon.com Fred McKinnon

          that’s pretty awesome about your son – be sure and let us know how that goes!

          • merry

            He had a great day. There was a high school student who is working on his Eagle Scout requirements, my son, and a grandfatherly-gentleman. They finished the project easily with the 3 of them, helped Scott complete one of his rank requirements, and then hung out for the rest of the day and played video games. My son was impressed that Mr. Wilson cooked a big supper for them all by himself ;)

  • http://www.robmckinnon.net Robert McKinnon

    I think it also has alot to do with how we see each other and ourselves. The twenty-something “doesn’t have anything in common” with the sixty-something year old. And vice versa.

    But when we see ourselves and each other FIRST as new creatures in Christ, we all have one thing in common.

    I’ve been reading in Galatians and Phillipians lately, and Paul keeps hammering in one thing: being of ONE MIND.

    When we stop demanding that “circumstances”, music, preaching, etc. be what WE want it to be and begin to realize that it’s supposed to be about GIVING, then the problem will disappear!

    That’s my 2 cents

  • http://www.OneVoiceWorship.org Harold Forbis

    These are great insights, and one common thread I see in them is the key — the focus has to be on God, not this group, or that group. It’s HIS house. If we look to Him, seek to please Him, minister to Him, He will have His way.

    That doesn’t mean we ignore people or don’t reach out. It just means that we believe and respond to the words of Jesus – that if we lift Him up, He will draw ALL men to Himself.

    Here’s 3 elements that make this work in the life of local churches:

    1. The presence of God must be among us – that prophetic element of the heavenly coming into the earthly, the eternal entering the now – is what marks us as the people of God. This dynamic sense of His presence in our lives, not just our meetings, draws us to Him and therefore draws us to one another, and solidifies our sense of family.

    2. Leaders and leadership teams must have genuine relationships with each other and with members of the congregation. Functioning families are lead by fathers, not managers. Within the context of family, members relate naturally to one another at all levels.

    3. Plentiful opportunities for purposeful, relationship-building fellowship must be created, like Merry’s talking about. Places to serve together, small group meetings that focus on the Word of God and prayer, etc., as well as backyard bbq’s and hang time (Acts 2:42-44).

    Fred, as always, thanks for getting us thinking!

  • Pingback: fmckinnon

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Age-Focused and Preference-Driven | FredMcKinnon.Com -- Topsy.com

  • http://www.journeyofworship.com Chris Gambill

    Amen!

    I’ve long maintained that until we stop treating the Sunday (or whenever) morning gathering as the end-all, be-all , satisfy-everything thing we’ve made it to be, we will continue to miss both the full expression of being the body of Christ and also helping people see and desire more. However, I’m finding that it is hard to sometimes recast thinking after years of treating the Sunday morning service as the place for worship, service, discipleship, community, missions, etc, etc, etc. We don’t offer a compelling reason for people to move beyond Sunday morning because we give them everything they think they need in that hour plus.

    I’m also relatively convinced that the goal of intergenerational worship togetherness is not going to be possible as long as people are more concerned with preferences and are not seeking to live in community and honor one another. Granted, I have yet to figure out what (if anything) to do about that. It also then begs the question of what to do with preferences and style (since those things aren’t all bad).

    I appreciate the thoughts and questions, I just would like to discover some answers or responses in this journey. Perhaps, just maybe, sometimes we try too hard…

subscribe by rsssubscribe by email facebooktwitter
twitter


  • About Me

    I'm a Christ Follower, Husband, Father, Worship Leader, Performer, and Entrepreneur ... more.
  • Compassion

    Sponsor a child online through Compassion's Christian child sponsorship ministry. Search for a child by age, gender, country, birthday, special needs and more.
  • Music Clearance

    CD + DVD: $5.00
    Worship Under the Stars - Live Worship
    CD + DVD: $5.00!
    Order Online!
  • RSS TWC Discussions

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Meta & RSS